Michelle Boccanfuso Nanouche, CSB Christian Science Practitioner & Teacher
  • THE HEALING PRACTICE
  • TEACHING
  • LECTURES
  • SCOPE OF SERVICES
  • FAQ
  • PUBLISHED CONTENT
  • MY YOUTUBE CHANNEL
  • ABOUT ME
  • CONTACT ME
  • RATES AND PAYMENT OPTIONS
  • PAY BILL ONLINE
  • THE HEALING PRACTICE
  • TEACHING
  • LECTURES
  • SCOPE OF SERVICES
  • FAQ
  • PUBLISHED CONTENT
  • MY YOUTUBE CHANNEL
  • ABOUT ME
  • CONTACT ME
  • RATES AND PAYMENT OPTIONS
  • PAY BILL ONLINE
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

2/1/2012

What we can learn from that crazy pig story

Picture
_ There is a great New Testament story that I think beautifully illustrates the importance of a spiritual perspective in healing. People refer to it as the Pig story or Swine story – which in a way makes the very point that the crazy pig part is what they remember most. You will find it in Mark, Chapter 5. And, oh my, it is a doozy.

There was this guy who had a legion of mental problems. Legion is a term indicating about 2000. Bound in chains to keep him under control, he lived in the tombs outside of town.

He had quite a problem, but it wasn’t what you might think. His problem involved a group of swine-herders working nearby. In this story swine-herder is simply another name for symptom-watcher, and they were good at their job! They watched this man rage and cry and cut himself while they herded swine in the neighborhood. They had seen all his 2000 symptoms over the years. They were convinced this man was a mess - a complicated case. They were afraid of both him and his problems.  It made sense that such a complicated case would require a complicated solution, right?


Picture
_Not necessarily. Jesus didn’t see the scene in quite the same way.  When he arrived, he simply saw a man - God’s man. Approaching him with compassion and without fear, Jesus heard the description of his legion of problems ~ problems the man so closely identified with himself that he considered Legion to be his own name. But after a brief, important conversation, Jesus was talking to a perfectly normal, healthy man, sitting before him clothed and in his right mind. 

But what did the swine-herders see? 

You see, when we read this account I believe that what we find are TWO stories woven together - two completely different perspectives of the same scene. Jesus came to Gadera alone.  There is no mention of other direct witnesses to this healing outside of the man and the swine-herders. These were the two reporters of what happened. One told a tale of peace and healing , while the other told a tale of grim horror. By separating out what Jesus actually did and said, from what would have interested the swine-herders, ie. references to their swine, we begin to see the two distinct points of view and the blending point where the accounts were brought together by someone (a swine-herder, most likely) saying Jesus was responsible for sending demons into the pigs.

This retelling of history plays out a bit like the creation account in chapters 1 and 2 of Genesis, which have two different authors writing from two different perspectives, but which over time and retelling have become so blended that many are convinced that the object lesson of Adam and Eve is an actual continuation of creation - as though they really existed and originated humanity.

Here, I will try to separate the two perspectives in the crazy pig story.

From Jesus’ viewpoint, he was approached by a man who believed he had a big problem. But after a simple conversation designed to identify who the man really was - a child of God created in the image of God, good, which is the perpetual message of the Christ to us - the man was perfectly well. Jesus cast out the belief that he could ever be anything but loved, lovable and lovely. It was a peaceful scene of healing.

Picture
_However, from the swine herder perspective, the story was horrific.  Rampant insanity couldn’t go down so easily!  What about all those symptoms they had been observing? 

Mary Baker Eddy wrote, "Mortal mind sees what it believes as certainly as it believes what it sees. It feels, hears, and sees its own thoughts." (Science and Health, p. 86)  Well, these poor fellows were ultimately victimized by their own point of view.  If their belief would only permit a complicated solution, they certainly got what they believed in the form of a pig sacrifice. Their swine went suicidal on them. They watched as 2000 of them - that works out to be one pig per symptom - ran crazily down the hill and off the cliff.

Did they ever even notice the man sitting and clothed in his right mind?  It doesn’t appear so.  Instead they took off for town to tell their terrible tale, missing the healing completely.  Is it any wonder the man asked Jesus if he could go away with him rather than going back into town with the swine-herders? 

Picture
_But Jesus wasn't afraid for him. He trusted that the truth would eventually win out in the long run. Jesus sent the man to town to explain what really happened. He was to stay there and show the townspeople that his healing was permanent.

We often hear it called the Swine story or Pig story, and many are confused by it to this day. Bible Commentaries are all over the map on it. In most cases their explanations are more confusing than they are a help.  And why? Because in the telling and retelling of a story, symptoms of problems can seem so impressive and cases so complicated, that it is easy to get distracted from the point. Instead of picking up on the most important elements of the story - what produced the actual healing - it is so easy to get pulled into the self-created drama of mortal mind. 

But we shouldn't lose sight of the fact that the suicidal swine only ever existed in the minds and experience of swine-herders, mortal minds mesmerized by symptoms. We don’t have to reconcile the bizarre bits of the story with the healing. They are the phenomena of mortal belief and nothing more.

Jesus met a man, had a chat about his real identity, helped him see that the problem was no part of him, and the man was healed by the Christly point of view. That’s it.

Don’t monitor problems and keep count of their symptoms. Let the Christ - God's message of your wholeness and goodness, speaking to your human consciousness - meet your concerns point by point, and lead you to a better view. Don't be afraid to sit humbly, quietly at the feet of this Christ message as you pray. And don't be surprised that when you do, you will discover yourself to be clothed in well-being and in full possession of your health.

No fuss. No muss. Healing is not as complicated as the swine-herders would have you believe.


_Did you enjoy this blog? Did you find it helpful?
The readership of this blog is growing by leaps and bounds everyday due to readers like you
- sharing, emailing, tweeting, and posting the link so that others can find it.

If you wish to subscribe to this blog, simply scroll up and submit your email in the box shown in the sidebar.

You may also wish to:
VISIT MY WEBSITE HOME PAGE
READ MORE BLOG POSTINGS
FIND LINKS TO MY OTHER PUBLISHED CONTENT
Marylyn Ponder
1/31/2012 10:34:23 pm

Yea! I like your version!

Michelle Nanouche link
2/1/2012 01:56:04 am

Thanks, Marylyn! You win for being the early bird this morning!

Amy Duncan
2/1/2012 05:31:39 am

Well, this was enlightening, to put it mildly! I know a lot of people have been troubled by this account, including myself, but this just makes so much sense, and you've also turned it into a reminder about how to pray for ourselves and others effectively. Thanks!

Michelle Nanouche link
2/1/2012 06:56:12 am

Gotta love those crazy pig stories! You are welcome, Amy.

Kathleen
2/1/2012 05:56:27 am

This story has always bothered me, but now I can see what the lesson here really is. We need to see as Jesus saw, and when we do, that clears up so many other issues, so many other "stories". Thanks, Michelle!

Michelle Nanouche link
2/1/2012 06:57:45 am

It always bothered me, too, Kathleen. And great point about the other "stories" - the little drama's we carry with us and call our very own!

Cyndy
2/1/2012 08:30:59 am

This is so helpful! - the explanation of this unusual story really makes sense! Very clear when explained this way. I never could really understand it before.Thanks so much -a strong reminder to hold the perfect model in thought no matter what the appearance!

Michelle Nanouche link
2/1/2012 08:35:48 am

Good, Cyndy! So glad it makes sense. Not such a complicated story when all the symptom's of confusion are pulled out of the narrative.

Dave
2/1/2012 08:45:15 am

In my own life I am in a situation right now with a relative in the hospital, and need to know the spiritual truth, and not see the material picture, just as you've described in your blog. So, this was very timely!

Michelle Nanouche link
2/1/2012 08:55:29 am

Oh, Dave, I have a feeling you aren't the only one. Just know that you are not mentally sitting at the foot of a hospital bed. You are sitting at the feet of the Christ. Let your consciousness be a no- drama zone. Then you won't miss all the healing going on. Sending so much love and support your way.

Michael
2/1/2012 09:49:34 am

What beautiful insight! Thanks so much, Michelle! That story makes so much more sense now. How important it is to not be watching for symptoms - I'd rather be a shepherd than a swine herder! Your blog posts are little gifts of inspiration that we can turn to everyday!

Michelle Nanouche link
2/1/2012 10:35:22 am

Thank you, Michael!

Kay
2/2/2012 08:32:31 am

Your insightful explanation goes a long way. Thanks so much!

Michelle Nanouche link
2/10/2012 12:19:18 pm

So glad, Kay. It is one of my favorite stories because it is so applicable in daily life.

Yves
2/28/2012 09:27:04 am


It is sometimes becoming an "absolute" necessity to save us from a flood, a legion, of populating beliefs and suggestions of despair eventually surrounding our mind from a so-called outside, even and above all if help is not formally asked for. And this text contains the solution... Incredible, simple and beautiful !
.
.

Michelle Nanouche link
2/29/2012 01:34:25 am

Thanks, Yves!

Laura Moliter link
3/12/2012 07:28:43 am

Thank you, Michelle. This is helpful as was today's (the March 12th) blog which included the link to this. I appreciate the inspired perspective on this story, and on the whole idea of trading symptom watching (and counting) for Christ-thinking (and healing).

Michelle Nanouche link
3/12/2012 10:34:20 am

You are welcome, Laura. This jumped out at me in reading Science and Health - "Mortal man has made a covenant with his eyes to belittle Deity with human conceptions. In league with material sense, mortals take limited views of all things." I think those limited views could be called SWINE! :)

Patty
8/31/2012 02:57:35 pm

I love your rendition of the crazy pig story. It's fresh and
believeable.

Michelle Nanouche
8/31/2012 03:16:34 pm

Glad you found it!

Beca Lewis link
10/17/2012 07:16:51 am

LOVE this Michelle!

Michelle Nanouche
10/17/2012 01:48:38 pm

Good, Beca! So glad you clicked through from today's post.

Agatha van Embden link
11/25/2012 06:57:42 pm

A clear explanation!
Do you know, Michelle, that nearly all links included are referring to "Harmony on the job."?


Comments are closed.
    Picture
    Français?

    Ask a question?
    Wish to receive blog updates? Enter your Email

    Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz

    RSS Feed

    Find me on YouTube​

    Michelle Nanouche, Christian Science teacher, spirituality, healing, prayer

    ​






    I have practiced Christian Science professionally in
    some form since 1979.
    But my journey with
    Christian Science started
    in a Sunday school
    where as a young child
    I was taught the Scriptures and some simple basics
    of Jesus' method of
    scientific Christian healing.
    A significant experience
    at the age of twelve
    opened my eyes to
    the great potential
    of this practice. 
    After impaling my foot
    on a nail,
    I prayed the way I had learned
    in Sunday school.
    Within moments
    the pain stopped
    and healing began.
    By the next morning the wound had disappeared completely.
    Having experienced
    the great potential
    ​of Christian Science,
    there would be no
    turning back. 

    Find out more
    Follow @mnanouchecsb
    Tweets by mnanouchecsb

    Archives

    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    September 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011

    Categories

    All 23rd Psalm About Michelle Abraham Abundance Abuse Action Actions Of Grace Adam Addiction Adultery Affirmation Afraid Of Questions Age Aging Alcohol All Amen Angels Angelsong Anger Angry Anxiety Arrest Evil Astrology Atmosphere Authority Awake Baby Back Pain Bad Days Balloon Balm In Gilead Barbara Pettis CSB Baseball Bbc-radio Bear-dreams Beatitudes Beauty Beauty-illusion Bedside Manner Beek Behold Betrayal Bible Bible Lesson Bible Translation Billing Blindness Blog Body Boyfriend Breaking Bad Habits Broken Toe Bruce K Waltke4a6f762dee Brylcream Burden Business Cancer Caption This Photo Caption This Photo76ad201eac Car Caroling Cat Celebrate Change Chaos Charity Chastity Chemicalisation Chicken Chicks Child Child Healing Children Choices Christ Christ Healing Christian Healing Christianity Christian Science Christian Science Practice Christian Science Practitioner Christine Dreissen Christ Jesus Christman Christmas Church Church Of Ephesus Class Instruction Clergy Killer Clutter College Communication Compassion Complaint Condemnation Conflict Congregations Connie Coddington Consent Contagion Contribution Control Coolidge Core Creation Creationism Crises Crisis Criticism Csb Daddy Daily Lift Daily Lift Daily Prayer Darkness Darwin Dating David Stevens Deafness Death Decisions Delight Depression Devil Diane Marrapodi Csb Diet Discipline Disconnected Disease Dislocated Leg Dislocation Distraction Divine Economy Divine Life Divorce Doctor Dog Dolly Parton Doubt Dreamer Dreams Dysfunction Eagle Easter Eating Ebola Doctor Editors Education Effective Egg Election Elijah Elise Moore Emotional Pain Employment England Envy Eternal Life Evan Mehlenbacher Evil Example Exercise Expunge Exterminator Ezekiel Faith Faithcure9041dbcdb0 Fall Family Family Conflict Father Fear Finding God Finding Your Prayer Mojo Find Your Prayer Mojo Fleas Flight Fly Focus Food Food Illnesses Foot Washing Forgiveness Found French-consulate Friendship Frustration Fully Funded Gender Generation Me Generation We Generation X Genesis Genesis 1134ab414725b George Ritchie Georgia-bulloch Georgia-bulloch-csb Getting Unstuck Ghosts Gift Gifts Giving Gluttony Goals God Godwords Going Home Good Good Deeds Goodness Good Will Gospel Grace Gratitude Grief Grocery Store Growth Guilt Habits Hagar Handwashing84dcc1ba2e Hanukkah Harvest Hate Headaches Healer Healing Healing Of Scabies Healing Prayer Health Hebrew Scripture Hell Helping Others Hitler Hoarding Holiday Preparations Holocaust Home Homeless Homeopathy Honesty Hopeless House Humanity Human Progress Humility Hurricane Hygiene Ichabod Crane Identity Illusion Immanuel Immigration Importunity Incorporeal Infertility Influence Influences Injustice Innocence Insanity Insistence Inspiration Integrity Internet Intuition Invisible Isaiah Isaiah 45 Ishmael Italy Jenny Burton Jessi Binnix Jesus Jewish Job Jonathan Pearson Joseph Joy Judas Judgment Julia Wade Kaleidoscope Karen Mandan Kate Robertson Kay Olson Kay Olson Csb Keith Wommack Kids Kindness Kingdom-of-god Kingdom Of Heaven Kitten Lameice Elaine Harding Language Laughter Lecture Legion Letting Go Life Light Lipstick Life Savers Loaves And Fish Lois Herr Csb Lord Loss Lost Love Love Note Love Yourself Lust Majesty Manhood Marcel Marceau Mark Swinney Marriage Mary Baker Eddy Mashupe451c72f2d Masks Material Law Material Sense Math Matter Media Medicine Memory Mental Influence Mental Sweat Mercy Messages Michelle Nanouche Mind Mindfulness Mindreading8c8b669ff4 Mission Mojo Monday Moral Code Morality Mormons Morning Has Broken Mortal Belief Moses Mother Motives Mountains Mourn Mouth Move Movement Moving On Nadia Bolzweber2632578709 Name Nehemiah Neighbors New Life New Opportunities News Newton New Year No Noise Nurse Obscene Calls Ocean O Holy Night Oil-well Omnipotence Omnipresence Omniscience Oprah Oprah-winfrey Oreos Pain Panic Paralysis Parent Parenting Passion Past Pastor Patience Patient Paul Pause Peacemaker Pearl Peeking Penn State Persecution Persistence Perspective Pest Control Peter Phenomena Pilates Plan Pneumonia Podcasts Politics Position When Praying Possibilities Poverty Powerhouse Power Of Truth Prayer Prayer For Self Prayer Heals Prayer In Church Prayer Mojo Pray First Pray For Children Premise Presence Presents Pride Principle Procrastination Prodigal Son Progress Project Psalms Public Service Public Speaking Publish Pull Punctuality Punctuation Puppy Purpose Radical Acts Radical Reliance Radio Rat Rats Reality Reflection Regret Relationships Remember Renewal Repationships Resistance Resolutions Resources Retrospection Return From Tomorrow Revelation Revision Road Rage Roots Rules Running Sabrina Stillwell Csb Sad Safety Salt Salvation Sand Bags Sarah Satan Scales Schools Sciatica Science And Health Scotland Second Isaiah Seeker Self Condemnation Selfcondemnation695d9c2fbc Self Destructive Selfdestructive515c04d53d Self Examination Selfexamination2b0941cdeb Self Image Selfimageccc8536b7c Selfless Love Selfrighteous5f6e4896b6 Sensuality Sermon Sermon On Mount Sermon On The Mount Seven Deadly Sins Sex Sexual Abuse Shame Shine Shoes Shoplifting Shopping Shut Up Silent Cal7dad7e1da9 Silent Prayer Simple Prayer Sin Sincerity Siyahamba Slab Sloth Smell Snakes Solutions Song Sorrow Soul Soulmate00b25c4b6c Space Spider Web Spirituality Spiritual Qualities Spiritual Sense Spiritual Study Sports Spring Star Stars Stealing Stepparent22b2fbb651 Stillbirth Storms Stress Stubborn Study Tools Substance Summer Supply Support Swine Swine Herder Swineherder0ca3e587ab Symptoms Synonyms Teacher Tears Technology Teenager Telephone Ten Commandments Testimony Thanksgiving Think Thought Thoughts Three Names Time Time Management Timing Tithe Tomb Trampoline Transparency Trapped Treatment Tree Trial Troublemakers Turbulence Ulrike Prinz Cs Universal Universe Up Victories Virgin Virginia Harris Vision Void Vote Walk On Water Warfare With Self Way Out Weather Whole World Why Pray Will Without Form Women Woody Allen World Wowbdde4b5c9f Writer Writing You Your Potential Zacchaeus

INFORMATION

ABOUT
FAQ
​PUBLISHED CONTENT

YOUTUBE CHANNEL

SERVICES

HEALING
LECTURES
TEACHING
​​ASSOCIATION

HELP

CONTACT
RATES
MAKE PAYMENT


Picture
© 2011-2021 Michelle Boccanfuso Nanouche, CSB. All rights reserved.  Pages reviewed and updates 6/30/2021.