Many years ago a friend and Christian healer told me that she had never read an article on healing the aftermath of a crushing disappointment. She thought that I should write one. The funny thing is that she often said this to me when I was in the depths of inconsolable despair, feeling that I was denied something I wanted terribly. I never felt qualified to give a healing response. But now, at 3:20 am on a Tuesday morning in October, I suddenly do. So here is that article. I had always longed to find and fulfill my unique niche. Life, to me, has been an adventure of discovering my role and my talents and putting them to good use. This search has opened amazing and wonderful doors. It’s also led to some closed doors that were difficult to move beyond. Soaring satisfaction with my life was sometimes interrupted by earth-shattering disappointment when opportunities I felt should be mine didn’t appear when and where I expected or wanted them. I have learned that we each really do have a niche, a role, an indispensable place, a particular mission in time and eternity. From a time sense, I mean that no one can replace any one of us in the individual and unique path of yielding to progress and divine good that we can call human experience. From an eternal perspective, not one single idea of God can be pushed, pulled or knocked off his unique and essential course as the reflection of the Almighty God. Christian Science founder Mary Baker Eddy once wrote, “No person can take the individual place of the Virgin Mary. No person can compass or fulfill the individual mission of Jesus of Nazareth. No person can take the place of the author of Science and Health, the Discoverer and Founder of Christian Science. Each individual must fill his own niche in time and eternity.” (Retrospection and Introspection , 70) I learned a few things about filling my niche when I applied to be a teacher of Christian Science. The Manual of The Mother Church – a document that provides for the offices and roles that support and sustain the healing practice of Christian Science worldwide – invites those who are qualified through their faithful healing practice to apply for what is called the Normal class. This class is an intensive training session that takes place once every three years for a select number out of many qualified applicants. Early on in my practice, I felt God was calling me to the teaching work, so I applied. I still remember walking out to our chicken house where my husband (my chief supporter/defender) was doing chores. I had the most tender and lovingly written rejection letter tumbling out of my hand. He thought someone had died when he first saw me. I was a blubbering, crying, inconsolable mess. It wasn’t that I had never been denied something I had wanted before. It was that I had never wanted to do anything this much before. I loved the practice of Christian Science. I saw it as my mission to practice and teach it. How could the right answer be “not now”? I thought there had to be some mistake. So in the remaining months preceding the class, I waited for a second missive to appear in the mail saying that an error had been discovered and that indeed I was welcome to come. That appeal never came. Over the next couple of years other wonderful doors did open for me. I threw all my energy into study of the Bible and the textbook that develops ones healing practice, Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures by Mary Baker Eddy. I found an outlet for my longing to teach through accepting an appointment as a Sunday School teacher for a big and active class of youngsters in my church. Requests for me to share inspiration from my study with a local nursing home in my community opened the way to an invitation to become a lecturer of Christian Science. When it came around again to application time for the Normal class, I felt the mental prod to apply. I just knew that for this class it would be my turn. Again, after the lengthy and thorough application process, I received a letter indicating “not this time.” If I thought the first “no” was rough, the second one felt worse. Without realizing it, my second application had become to me something of a litmus test for the approval of others. “Now am I good enough?” was a latent, undermining question poisoning my thought. As experience tells us, while sadness and disappointment really stink, throw anger into that mix and the feelings are infinitely worse. And I was angry – at God for dangling this opportunity under my nose and not letting me do it. (Oh, what a miserable, limited concept of the infinite Love that is the true God, I suffered from. ) I was angry at those who had worked with me so painstakingly during the application process. Why did they make me feel so appreciated and valued, when the plan was to deny me what I wanted to do? I was angry at myself. Who did I think I was to ask to teach? Why did I put myself through all this again, knowing the risks and how hard it was for me to be rejected? To come out of the deep depression that settled on me following this disappointment, I had to dump the anger. It didn’t happen all at once, but through persistently continuing with the good habits I had already developed of praying for me daily to be kept from sin; of growing my understanding of the true nature of God and man through my regular study of the Bible and Science and Health; of serving in church in the roles that were offered to me; of developing further my practice of Christian healing for others; the anger and disappointment were replaced by spiritual growth. Out of the ashes of the second disappointment came a new opportunity – to address the annual meeting of an Association of Pupils of a Christian Science teacher who had passed on. I loved the opportunity to teach that came through this invitation. It confirmed everything I longed to do. It was fun - and hard work. And after this first invitation was fulfilled, others quickly followed. My calendar began filling with annual opportunities to work with Pupil’s Associations for many years to come. But as satisfying as this was, my eye was still on that next Normal class. Surely THAT one was mine. So when the time came around again, I applied. This time little interest was shown in my application. The process seemed less involved. I counted that as meaning that I was a shoo-in. (Ever the positive thinker!) I figured, God knows I am ready now. And I really think I was, but I was not to be in that class. My husband passed on suddenly two months before the start date. Around the same time, I received the same letter. I was disappointed to not be invited, but I was so occupied with dealing with the emotions of my husband’s passing, as well as the life-details that demanded my attention, that one more shock over not being invited to Normal class seemed that – just one more shock. Three years later my outlook was much more humble than it had been before. I applied for the Normal class, but fulfilling my role as a single mom of a teenage daughter was a higher priority. While I still felt called to teach, the urgency and push I had felt before were no longer there. So although I was disappointed to not be in the class that year – yes, the answer was again a no – I wasn’t terribly knocked over by the news. I felt something new and good was in store for me. I had hoped it was teaching, but I was no longer using the application process as a test of my worth. I knew I was loved and valued by God and by others. I loved and valued myself. I was now open to new opportunities in whatever form they should be presented. I felt God’s guidance and protection as I moved forward with my life. The month following that Normal class I was invited to take a trip to Paris with a friend and everything changed for me. (Listen to an eleven minute podcast that fills you in on those details.) During the next three years there were many new and unexpected developments. I married a Frenchman. I moved to France. I started learning a new language. When it came time again to apply for the class, I honestly didn’t feel called by God to do it. I was willing to teach - the desire was still apparent - but I didn’t see how it would be possible. If I became a teacher in France, my language skills weren’t up where they would need to be. So for the first time in 12 years, I didn’t apply. Then after three more years, I felt the call, did apply, and was accepted into the Normal class. Today, the whole long story seems a bit dream-like. I have memories of the disappointment and of feelings of being blocked, but the angst has been completely replaced with an overview perspective of steady development and progress that really define those years. I could never have foreseen at the time of the first, second, third and fourth applications – and especially not during the one that I skipped – that my niche for fulfilling the deep desire to teach would include a foreign country and another language. I am not the same teacher I might have been otherwise. And now I wouldn’t have it any other way. A great lesson for me has been to understand that our true niche isn’t a destination. It’s our place in infinity. We aren’t en route to that place. It is included in our very identity as the present and operational reflection of God. Everything developing in me to be doing what I now do was always mine, always with me, in me. Intuition discerned the capacity to teach. Deep desire and the nurturing of my spirituality through prayer and study erased all traces of disappointment and the personal ambition it pointed to, and opened the way to the revelation, one by one, of the divine qualities of patience, persistence, focus, unflagging faith, spiritual energy, renewal, resilience, self-worth, confidence, obedience, and humility that are inherent in every child of God, and essential to the expression of each one’s unique role in the universe. Ultimately, no one will miss the boat. We include our niche. And while its discovery in us may seem to occur in time, that is just a human perspective of unfolding good. I think this human perspective is what Mary Baker Eddy was referring to when she gave this sage advice: “We must resign with good grace what we are denied, and press on with what we are, for we cannot do more than we are nor understand what is not ripening in us. To do good to all because we love all, and to use in God’s service the one talent that we all have, is our only means of adding to that talent and the best way to silence a deep discontent with our shortcomings.” But looking beyond the human to the divine and present fact of our place in eternity, she continued, “Christian Science is at length learned to be no miserable piece of ideal legerdemain, by which we poor mortals expect to live and die, but a deep-drawn breath fresh from God, by whom and in whom man lives, moves, and has deathless being” (First Church of Christ, Scientist, and Miscellany).
43 Comments
Dea
10/14/2014 12:04:30 am
So unblushingly honest... So clear in showing how your thinking and actions moved through the process... So inspiring in moving me to watch, work, yearn, seek, reach for my niche in time and eternity... Merci beaucoup Michelle...
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 01:13:01 am
Thank you, Dea. And you are welcome. Some posts write themselves. This one poured out whole from beginning to end. It was a middle of the night, waking inspiration. I had to get out of bed and write it down. Glad to know it meets a need.
Reply
Teri
10/14/2014 02:27:40 am
Wow, that was expressed so beautifully! I am grateful that you elaborated on that MBE passage about finding our niche. I have come across that several times during this long lapse of unemployment and career transition, all the while pondering it further. Your explanation was very helpful as well as your own shared experiences of disappointment and how you addressed them prayerfully.
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 03:01:39 am
Thank you, Teri. Nothing, no one, can hide your niche from you. Every experience you are having right now is opening it to you and you to it. Cherish each moment.
Reply
Elena Shideler
10/14/2014 02:56:35 am
Thank you so much, Michelle, for this, because I can feel it came from the heart. I can identify with the feeling of emptiness, it leaves you puzzled and feeling helpless.
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 03:02:44 am
Very kind, Elena. Thank you for your understanding. It is so very nice to hear from you here.
Reply
Leah Eselgroth
10/14/2014 05:18:39 am
Thank you Michelle dear for this candid, open look at the steps you worked though in achieving the demonstration of your own niche, which actually did include you becoming a Teacher of Christian Science. Your experience 'teaches' us to not give up but to release our desires to God, 'Desire is prayer; and no loss can occur from trusting God with our desires, that they may be moulded and exalted before they take form in words and in deeds.' [S&H pg. 1] I love realizing that you had to move to France, master the language, marry a beautiful man as part of your 'gracious preparation'. Understanding this opens our eyes to the fact, that God thinks BIG and we need to let go and let God have His way with us, for it will prove to be much greater in scope and blessing than can outline for ourselves. [And your lesson in humility is not lost on us either...:) ] Thank you again, bless you for your patience.
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:35:28 pm
I big thank you to you for your encouraging words and good ideas, Leah.
Reply
Janet
10/14/2014 05:47:06 am
Dear Michelle, what a beautiful expression of hope you gave me this morning. As the others have commented, you are so clear and that clarity is so helpful to so many of us. You teach every time you post a blog. And as students of CS, we all learn and grow from your growth and insight. I've been struggling with "my niche" and I thank you for the loving support!
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:36:09 pm
You've got it, dear Janet.
Reply
10/14/2014 05:54:58 am
This was both incredibly moving and inspiring at the same time. Thank you for sharing this with all of us Michelle.. I will be thinking about it for a long time. And thank you for your persistence, we have all benefited from it!
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:36:54 pm
Persistence has never been a struggle. Patience on the other hand... :) Thank you, Beca.
Reply
Cynthia Tyler
10/14/2014 06:43:43 am
Amazing journey, Michelle... Thank you for sharing this so openly and clearly. It is inspiring beyond words... Your persistence and dedication to fulfilling the deepest desire within you is a beacon. Thank you for your life example
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:37:49 pm
Lovely special message. Thank you, Cyndy.
Reply
grace
10/14/2014 07:44:17 am
Your candor is refreshing, Michelle. God has planted you right where you were meant to be and given you your "dream job" in His own timing and way. Such a sweet lesson in persistence, humility, and patience. Such blessings to be had! Merci!
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:38:27 pm
Thank you, Grace.
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:39:00 pm
Great, Alex. Encouraging. Thank you.
Reply
Kelly Townsend
10/14/2014 09:18:13 am
Michelle, thank you for sharing this. I'm reading this on tuesday morning and *divine timing for me. It is so specific a piece in "my own curriculum" currently going on, particularly after a mind and heart clearing, opening and expanding conversation just yesterday. And, whenever I see the digits 3 2 0 -- I immediately consider Ephesians 3:20 (all of E/3 actually), and this is double-ing the message for me. Much love and appreciation.
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:40:15 pm
So good, Kelly. Thank you.
Reply
Jan Heining
10/14/2014 10:05:04 am
Dear Michelle,
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:40:46 pm
You are welcome, Jan!
Reply
Betty
10/14/2014 11:46:02 am
Dear Michelle,
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:41:38 pm
Loyal and faithful readers like you keep this blogger blogging! Thank you, Betty.
Reply
Sue S.
10/14/2014 11:48:13 am
Thank you Michelle! From bud to full blossom, what a tender, heartfelt and meaningful testimony this is in overcoming disappointment and seeing "the gold refined."
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 12:53:33 pm
Thank you for sharing that, Sue. Very precious experiences. Maybe it was! I don't know which was yours, but I did a bunch. And they were all heavenly experiences for me. ;)
Reply
Wendy Rose
10/14/2014 01:41:29 pm
Thank you so much, Michelle, for your captivating account of spiritual growth…never giving up. Your energy, vigor, happiness just kept on being given channels of love for so many…including me now. Lying down and giving up in self-absorption just wasn't your character…your unselfish and unselfed loving couldn't lie down in defeat, so thanks for sharing how hard you worked, the tears and triumphs, and proving your patience and trust in God. Huge help to me. I really appreciate your essays - teaching and ministering - and their accounts of joyful living. As Keith Wommack says "Nothing Can Stop Your Go!" Thank you for being a Teacher of Christian Science!
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 02:03:45 pm
I have to remember that one. It's great! Everyone is being so generous in their comments. Thank you, Wendy!
Reply
Amy
10/14/2014 01:44:28 pm
Wow, Michelle, what an experience! I could so relate to your experience...it seems so hard sometimes just to let go when things aren't going our way or seem impossible. But God is always there, whispering (or shouting!) "Trust me...it's all right...you can trust me..." and sooner or later we get it! Thanks so much for telling your story.
Reply
Michelle
10/14/2014 02:06:59 pm
You are right, Amy. Thanks for speaking up and sharing. This post has had a pretty amazing response. I wrote ir and then went to work. Came home and pow-y comments galore and all over Facebook. I so appreciate everyone's appreciation and sharing.
Reply
Caryn
10/15/2014 06:29:33 am
After reading your humanly honest and divinely truthful blog, felt a gentle, deep sense of calm and peace. Dear Michelle, thank you for your much needed and appreciated writing & sharing. Holy Wow!!
Reply
Michelle
10/15/2014 11:28:15 am
I am so grateful to know, Caryn. Thank you!
Reply
Cindy
10/15/2014 10:02:59 am
I think one reason this post is having such an impact is it fills a void in the messaging about what it means to follow Christ in the daily practice of Christian Science. We have plenty of articles, blogs, podcasts about success, healing, and other preferred outcomes. But it can be disheartening for a long-time Christian Scientist to feel they are the only ones who've ever felt temporarily defeated, because we read so little about the human struggle. But even Jesus' closest disciples felt the sting of confusion, disappointment, rejection, and feelings of inadequacy.
Reply
Michelle
10/15/2014 11:25:08 am
Cindy, you nailed it. Deeply insightful and right on. I may need to pull part of your comment out and highlight it on this blog. Not everyone digs deep into the comments. But I think your summary of true Christianity and its demands is essential. Thank you and so much love.
Reply
Sandra
10/17/2014 03:08:28 am
Well, this must be an angel message to "stumble" upon (looking for something else) at 4 a.m. after feeling defeated by a tough week, sense of setback and wrong directions. All while continuing to deal with the seemingly unhealable. Thanks so much for putting this out here. It surely helps pull me out of a sense of no where to go, too much, for too long, and too late.
Reply
Michelle
10/19/2014 12:53:57 am
Hi Sandra, Be sure to listen to the podcast noted in the post. It touches the subject of the move more directly, and shows the thought process involved, as well as the human footsteps.
Reply
kevnc
10/20/2014 03:45:07 pm
Thank you so much for this, Michelle, and to the readers who've replied. I've had much in my life that parallels your experience (though the specifics are very different). As a musical artist, I've had to learn close up and personal about rejection -- and it happens all too often in my day job career too! (In fact it goes on as I write this.)
Reply
Michelle
10/21/2014 02:38:46 am
Right to the point! I am pretty sure that arriving at that understanding required a good clear sense of yourself as expressing your "niche" so that rejection and disappointment don't knock you around.
Reply
Kelly
10/21/2014 09:11:55 am
Oh thank you for that "God is my appointment secretary so my agenda is always full" -- and all of these posts are Very Helpful ! Thanks everyone for sharing.
Michelle
10/21/2014 09:15:34 am
You are welcome, Kelly. That has saved me from fear and stress innumerable times. Also, it has helped me not to be overwhelmed when I have a lot to do. God, Mind, knows me and my capabilities way better than even I do.
Kathleen
10/21/2014 11:24:29 am
Thank you, Michelle, for this heart-felt account of rejection. We've all been there, but it can be difficult to discuss while we are still in the middle of it. And when it is all over and happily resolved, I find that I am so busy moving on, that the road ahead is all that matters, and the disappointing road behind has almost been forgotten. It's ok to forget the heart ache. But what I do enjoy returning to is the state of marveling that God had everything under control all along, and the deep gratitude that results from this realization. It makes it so much easier to handle seeming roadblocks again, because now I know "God is working His purpose out".
Reply
Michelle
10/21/2014 11:53:16 am
Hello Kathleen, thanks for that!
Reply
D_oroBlunck
4/6/2017 09:55:01 pm
Thank you Michelle!
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Find me on YouTube I have practiced Christian Science professionally in some form since 1979. But my journey with Christian Science started in a Sunday school where as a young child I was taught the Scriptures and some simple basics of Jesus' method of scientific Christian healing. A significant experience at the age of twelve opened my eyes to the great potential of this practice. After impaling my foot on a nail, I prayed the way I had learned in Sunday school. Within moments the pain stopped and healing began. By the next morning the wound had disappeared completely. Having experienced the great potential of Christian Science, there would be no turning back. |
INFORMATION |
SERVICES |
HELP |
© 2011-2024 Michelle Boccanfuso Nanouche, CSB. All rights reserved. Pages updated July 1, 2024.